Sign In
Join/Renew
ACEP ID:
My Account
My CME
Sign Out
✕
Topics
TOPICS
Clinical Alerts
Corporatization
Scope of Practice
Workforce
Unionization
Reproductive Health
Violence in the ED
Opioids
Insurer Bad Practices
QUICK ACCESS
Find a Physician Group
Find a Residency
Find a Job
CURRENT NEWS
ACEP Now
Annals of Emergency Medicine
JACEP Open
News Releases
Practice
ADMINISTRATION
Reimbursement
Crowding & Boarding
Accreditation Programs
Diversity, Inclusion & Health Equity
Health Information Technology
Quality
EM Data Institute
PATIENT CARE
Clinical Policies
Point-of-Care Tools
Policy Statements
PREPs
Sponsored Content
Ultrasound
Social EM
LIFE AS A PHYSICIAN
Careers
Well-Being
Medical & Legal Resources
Contracts
Practice Essentials
ACEP Insurance
CAREER PATH
EMS
Medical Director
Small Group
Research
Rural
Education
CME
Free CME for Members
Continuing Medical Education
Maintenance of Certification
CME Tracker
Apply for CME
MEETINGS
Annual Meeting
Virtual Annual Meeting
Course Proposals
Other Meetings
Event Calendar
DIGITAL EDUCATION
ACEP Anytime
Online Learning Center
Critical Decisions (CDEM)
PEER
Webinars
MicroED
OTHER EDUCATION
Bookstore
Journals & Pubs
Podcasts & Apps
Advocacy
FEDERAL ADVOCACY
Federal Overview
Surprise Billing
Workforce
Clinician Well-Being
Mental Health
Medicare & Medicaid
Reimbursement
Workplace Violence
Liability Reform
STATE ADVOCACY
State Overview
Liability Reform
Out of Network Billing
Effective Tools
Psychiatric Holds
Medicaid
Case Studies
GET INVOLVED
Advocacy Action Center
911 Grassroots Network
NEMPAC
Leadership & Advocacy Conference (LAC)
GROUPS TO JOIN
911 Grassroots Network
About ACEP
WHO WE ARE
Our Values
Strategic Plan
About Us
ACEP Awards
News Releases
HOW WE SERVE
Leadership
Sections
Interest Groups
Committees
Council
Chapters
MEMBERSHIP
Renew Your Membership
Explore Membership
ACEP in Action
Member Benefits
Eligibility & Dues
engagED Communities
American College of Emergency Physicians
/
Journals & Publications
/
Annals of Emergency Medicine
/
Annals Author Survey
Annals Author Survey
*1. Compared to other journals you've submitted to, did you find Annals prompt and responsive?
1 - Slow
2
3 - Average
4
5 - Prompt
N/A
*2. Did you feel the review process improved your manuscript?
1 - Made it worse
2
3 - Unchanged
4
5 - Improved
N/A
*3. Were our communications and reviews courteous, knowledgeable, and helpful to you?
1 - Unhelpful
2
3 - Average
4
5 - Helpful
N/A
*4. After this peer review experience at Annals, would you be likely to submit to us again, or recommend us to other researchers?
1 - Never again
2
3 - So-so
4
5 - Very likely
N/A
*5. Did you benefit from the comments provided by the peer reviewers? (Does not include comments from the editor).
Yes
No
N/A
*6. Did they suggest any new ideas or new solutions that were not initially in your paper?
Yes
No
N/A
*7. If they did, did you incorporate any of their suggestions into the manuscript?
Yes
No
N/A
*8. Did they identify any errors (other than minor ones like spelling, grammar, etc) in the manuscript?
Yes
No
N/A
*9. Did they misunderstand any major aspect of your manuscript?
Yes
No
N/A
*10. Please rate your assessment of Annals efforts (which are based on ICMJE recommendations) to standardize reporting of authors' potential conflicts of interest.
1 - Inappropriate, excessive, provides no potential benefit in assessing the quality of the research
2
3
4
5 - Reasonable, thoughtful, necessary to help editors and reviewers assess the quality of research
What was the single best part of your peer review experience?
12. What was the worst part of your peer review experience?
13. If your primary specialty is outside EM, please name your specialty:
14. If you normally submit to journals in specialties other than emergency medicine, why did you submit this manuscript to Annals?
15. If your specialty is NOT emergency medicine,what could we do to make it more attractive to you to submit papers to us?
16. Manuscript Number (Please add the manuscript number (eg, 2006-725) of your submission if you are willing. This is not mandatory, and will only be used to anonymously link your feedback so we can identify the editor and reviewers involved in the review of your manuscript for our quality improvement.):
Submit
Submit
© 2024 American College of Emergency Physicians.
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
[
Feedback →
]